Customer Experience: Moving Away from Pure Self-Service to Welcome the Augmented Advisor

Caroline Jéséquel, Group Managing Director, Magellan

Caroline Jéséquel from Magellan discusses the future of customer experience, focusing on the shift from fully automated self-service to the augmented adviser.

Long dominated by the myth of complete self-service, the customer relations sector is undergoing a decisive shift. However, this is not a step backwards, but a change of focus: AI should no longer seek to replace the adviser, but to make them irreplaceable.

The illusion of the autonomous chatbot

Just a few years ago, the promise was simple, almost enticing: chatbots capable of handling virtually all customer journeys autonomously, without any human intervention. Full automation was supposed to free organisations from the cost of human contact, whilst offering round-the-clock availability.

Reality soon caught up with the promise. When dealing with high-stakes or emotionally charged issues (complaints, unpaid bills, claims, etc.), the autonomous chatbot revealed its limitations: journeys perceived as rigid, an inability to deviate from the script, and an almost systematic redirection to an advisor as soon as the enquiry became more complex. Customers, for their part, paid the price for this rigidity: frustration, a feeling of not being listened to, and the impression of wasting time before finally speaking to a human representative.

The consequences were long underestimated. An ineffective chatbot does not merely damage the brand’s reputation: it creates a double burden for the customer service representative, who, at the end of the line, is left dealing with a customer already exasperated by the machine and must also repair the relationship before they can even address the initial enquiry.

The limitation is, in fact, structural. An autonomous chatbot knows how to optimise the resolution of simple cases. It does not know – and will probably never know on its own – how to optimise the quality of the relationship.

A shift already underway

This observation is no longer an isolated one. Among our major clients (in banking, insurance, the public sector, etc.), we observe a clear reallocation of AI budgets: away from fully automated solutions, and towards the co-piloted adviser.

This shift is not an admission of failure on the part of artificial intelligence. On the contrary, it is a sign of a market that is maturing. We are moving away from the phase of theoretical experimentation – where the aim was to prove that machines could replace humans – and into a phase of operational utility, where the aim is to prove that machines can enhance human capabilities.

The figures confirm this shift. In practice, we are seeing a 90% adoption rate of AI features by advisers within less than three months when the tool is designed to assist them rather than bypass them – a level of uptake rarely seen in technological rollouts. Customer attitudes point in the same direction. Gartner found that while 50% of customers say interactions are easier when companies use GenAI, 87% consider it essential to retain the option of reaching a human agent.* The message is clear: customers increasingly value what AI brings to the experience, but not when it becomes a barrier to human support.

The new model: the augmented adviser

The model that is emerging is neither an all-human approach nor an all-chatbot approach, but rather that of the augmented adviser.

In practical terms, this takes the form of automatic summaries of the customer’s history, real-time response suggestions during the interaction, and contextualised access to internal knowledge, without the adviser having to navigate through ten different tools to find the information.

One rule governs this model: the ‘last click’ principle. AI summarises, suggests and speeds things up, but humans remain the sole authority when it comes to validating and embodying the customer relationship. It is the human who decides, who adds nuance, and who represents the brand in the interaction.

The results are tangible. We’ve seen a reduction of up to 30% in processing time for written messages, and 80% of digital enquiries are dealt with in under four hours. These gains do not stem from automation that bypasses the advisor, but from automation that supports them.

The conditions for success

This shift places three demands on management teams responsible for customer relations.

Firstly, customer trust must remain the key criterion when selecting tools, taking precedence over cost and raw technical performance. A tool that becomes more efficient but erodes trust ultimately fails on both counts.

Secondly, the key to success is not technological, but human: team buy-in takes precedence over the sophistication of AI. A tool that advisers do not use, or use reluctantly, will never deliver the promised benefits.

Finally, the nature of the competitive battle has changed. It will no longer be decided by who has the best chatbot, but by who has the best-supported advisers. This is a significant shift in the playing field: competitive advantage is no longer built solely on the technological layer, but on the ability to make humans and machines work together.

Conclusion

Customer relations are not about choosing between humans and machines, but about ensuring they work well together. The fully autonomous approach promised radical simplicity; it came up against a stubborn reality: trust cannot be automated. The organisations that will pull ahead will not be those with the most sophisticated chatbots, but those that have managed to put AI at the service of their teams rather than in their place.

* Gartner, August 2026, survey of 3,566 B2B and B2C customers, conducted February–March 2026.

About the Author

Caroline Jéséquel is Group Managing Director at Magellan, and a member of the Board of Directors.

Previously she served as CEO of Mobility and eTransactional Services at Worldline, a business unit specializing in building and operating digital and critical services, across the EU, the UK and India. She has a strong knowledge of the banking sector, the public sector, and transport industries.

She has more than 30 years of experience in Consulting and IT Services, spanning sales leadership, operations management, transformational aspects, and the management of a large-scale international business unit.

Find out more about Magellan https://www.magellangroup.eu/products/cx-suite/

Leave a Comment